Warning : this page is computer-translated from a french page of this site. Automatically translated pages are not always perfect and may contain errors in vocabulary, syntax or grammar (probably similar to the errors that would make a foreigner speaking in your language!). The original page, in french, could be find
here...
This test is to measure the
ability of software to be collected as usable emails. This characteristic is
relatively important since it determines the ability of software to thwart
anti-spam and clean results, apart from any considerations of screening and / or
selectivity.
Protocol
We always gave each software
all pages to be scanned (the ability to discover and explore links here being
set aside). We then counted the total number of mails we have captured and
counted the number of mails actually exploitable collected (each mail to be
collected in exactly the form mail-xx@websynaptics.com where xx is between 00
and 99).
We set each software to ensure that all options for cleaning and
circumvention are enabled. Obviously, one result was expected to find 100 emails
which provides a note on 100.
Raw results
| Publisher |
Software |
Version |
Total |
Exploitable |
| AALWAY Editions |
AspiWeb |
2.96 |
31 |
24 |
| ASP Magazine |
E-mail eXtractor |
1.0 |
35 |
28 |
| AtomPark Software |
Atomic Email Hunter |
4.44 |
34 |
25 |
| Editeur inconnu |
WebExtract |
2.10 |
24 |
24 |
| Editeur inconnu |
Email Grabber |
2.00 |
5 |
4 |
| eMarkSofts |
Target Email Extractor |
1.2 |
32 |
25 |
| eMarkSofts |
Fast Email Harvester |
1.2 |
32 |
25 |
| ETOYI Technology |
Email Spider Easy |
4.99 |
25 |
25 |
| FlashMailCast |
Super Email Extractor |
2.85 |
28 |
28 |
| FlashMailCast |
Super Email Spider |
2.84 |
28 |
28 |
| MailUtilities |
Advanced Email Extractor |
2.96 |
29 |
16 |
| MazePath |
Internet Email Address Extractor |
3.0.0.5 |
9 |
9 |
| Proxymis |
Mailing Builder |
9.0.0 |
31 |
24 |
| Softiciel Solutions |
Captimails |
1.11 |
32 |
26 |
| Sven Bader |
onl!ne email grabber professional |
1.3 |
28 |
28 |
| TicTacMail |
TicTacMail |
1.2 |
40 |
33 |
| Tukanas Software |
Tukanas Email Extractor |
2.0 |
0 |
0 |
| WebSynaptics |
MailWalker |
1.1.0 |
100 |
100 |
Weighted results
To obtain a final ranking
which disadvantages the software that are few mails and / or who do not clean
their results, we considered that the final would be equivalent to the number of
usable emails found decreased by half the difference (total decreased the number
of farms). This number was converted into percentages to obtain the final
ranking on the ability to collect email addresses "clean." The higher the
percentage, the greater is the software quality in the collection directly
exploitable:
| Publisher |
Software |
Version |
Weighted result |
| AALWAY Editions |
AspiWeb |
2.96 |
21% |
| ASP Magazine |
E-mail eXtractor |
1.0 |
25% |
| AtomPark Software |
Atomic Email Hunter |
4.44 |
21% |
| Editeur inconnu |
WebExtract |
2.10 |
24% |
| Editeur inconnu |
Email Grabber |
2.00 |
4% |
| eMarkSofts |
Target Email Extractor |
1.2 |
22% |
| eMarkSofts |
Fast Email Harvester |
1.2 |
22% |
| ETOYI Technology |
Email Spider Easy |
4.99 |
25% |
| FlashMailCast |
Super Email Extractor |
2.85 |
28% |
| FlashMailCast |
Super Email Spider |
2.84 |
28% |
| MailUtilities |
Advanced Email Extractor |
2.96 |
10% |
| MazePath |
Internet Email Address Extractor |
3.0.0.5 |
9% |
| Proxymis |
Mailing Builder |
9.0.0 |
21% |
| Softiciel Solutions |
Captimails |
1.11 |
23% |
| Sven Bader |
onl!ne email grabber professional |
1.3 |
28% |
| TicTacMail |
TicTacMail |
1.2 |
30% |
| Tukanas Software |
Tukanas Email Extractor |
2.0 |
0% |
| WebSynaptics |
MailWalker |
1.1.0 |
100% |
Comments